Male Athletes
- 1986 - Michael Jacobson
- 1987 - Eugene Peppers
- 1988 - Aaron Hueman
- 1989 - Paul Talbot
- 1990 - Bill Eisenstein
- 1991 - Josh Folk
- 1992 - Dave Das
- 1993 - Steve Thorn
- 1994 - Aaron O'Connor
- 1995 - Jeff Thorn
- 1996 - Damian Marshall
- 1997 - Jeff Kang
- 1998 - Adam Reynolds
- 1999 - Jeff Helfrich, Sammy Sohn, Luke Walczewski
- 2000 - Tyson Masar
- 2001 - Ben Leff, Galen Reeves
- 2002 - Noah Zych
- 2003 - Matt Sutton, David Slichter
- 2004 - Tianyu Qi
- 2005 - Henry Pollock
- 2006 - Al Renner
- 2007 - Michael Belmont
- 2008 - Austin Rundus
- 2009 - Malcolm Taylor
- 2010 - Dan Lilly
- 2011 - Albert Anastasio
- 2012 - Tahar Bowen-Pinto
- 2013 - Patrick Wong, George Voulgaris
- 2014 - George Gunter
- 2015 - Isaak Haberman
- 2016 - Chris Bauer, Panos Voulgaris
- 2017 - Varun Chopra
- 2018 - Noah Blue
- 2019- Asante Woods
- 2020- Henry Kraatz
- 2021- Lucas Wood
- 2022- Henry Laufenberg
Female Athletes
- 1986 - Sophia Neely, Monique Brown, Shella Findley
- 1987 - Iris Kurman
- 1988 - Sylvia Knust
- 1989 - Tamar Shapiro
- 1990 - Allison Wickens
- 1991 - Bridget O'Connor
- 1992 - Amy Parker
- 1993 - Molly Robin-Abbot
- 1994 - Laurel Herendeen
- 1995 - Cindy Wang
- 1996 - Christina Garcia, Bridget Rogers
- 1997 - Amanda Smeltzer
- 1998 - Emily Brothers, Megan Murphy
- 1999 - Liz Pollock
- 2000 - Sara Medendorp
- 2001 - Michelle Bryne
- 2002 - Joanna Cranston, Andrea Goodall, Kate Murphy
- 2003 - Veronica Zych
- 2004 - Clarabelle Devries, Teresa Sonka
- 2005 - Molly Smith
- 2006 - Josie Chambers
- 2007 - Mandy Grill
- 2008 - Michelle Mehnart, Ruthie Welch
- 2009 - Rachel Skoza
- 2010 - Michelle Wong
- 2011 - Heather Lin
- 2012 - Jamie Blue
- 2013 - Emma Hoyer
- 2014 - Lea Slauch
- 2015 - Grace Lilly
- 2016 - Maddie Nelson
- 2017 - Annemarie Michael
- 2018 - Ema Rajic and Arielle Summitt
- 2019- Macheila Anderson
- 2020- Kristine Wang
- 2021- Reed Broaders
- 2022- Sally Ma