Welcome, Guest!

Blog: A sinking feeling

I'm not a senior and I'm not even planning on going to prom. But a Titanic-themed prom?

April 14, the day of 2012 prom, is the centenary of the sinking of the RMS Titanic, an event where more than 1500 people died. An appropriate way to respond to or commemorate that event might be an informational movie night, or perhaps a discussion of the Titanic's "unsinkable" construction and why it actually failed.

For those who don't know already, this year's prom theme will be "A Night to Remember," a theme that comes verbatim from a 1955 Walter Lord novel based on the sinking of the Titanic, and then a 1958 film based on the book. The leaps of logic involved in getting the prom theme out of an anniversary of an event that was retold in a book and movie would certainly impress the likes of Glenn Beck.

Holding prom themed as "A Night to Remember" on the anniversary of the Titanic's sinking is inappropriate in so many ways. According to the email, junior and senior students will be invited to join the junior class officers in "recreating the experience of sailing on the majestic Titanic at Prom 2012: a night filled with fun, food, and dancing!"

Now, I'm not trying to ruin the fun of prom--not even remotely--nor am I trying to insult the junior class officers or the prom committee. But if we are to recreate the experience of sailing on the Titanic, it would involve more panicking, drowning, and dying than the 2012 prom (hopefully) will, and conversely, if it is to be a night of fun, prom 2012 should almost certainly not seek to recreate the experience of sailing on the Titanic.

I understand the fact that the Titanic and the partying on it was going swimmingly until the iceberg was struck, but that is not what most people remember about the Titanic--not the dancing, not the partying, not the music, but tragedy and disaster.

I wonder what it is, what distance, makes this tasteless theme so acceptable: is it the time factor? Surely if we were to have a Costa Concordia prom--after a disaster that happened this year and killed 25--it would be totally unacceptable to commemorate the event in that way.

Besides, April 14 was also the day Lincoln was assassinated--why not have a Lincoln assassination-themed prom? Or we could celebrate literally any other historical event that just happened to be on April 14, be it the end of Nazi occupation of Croatia in 1945, the foundation of the first American abolitionist organization in 1775, or the production of the first Volvo in 1927.

Or maybe the prom theme is supposed to be metaphorical? We're all sailing on the ship of life, but unbeknownst to us, the iceberg of (something) is looming in the distance, waiting to sink us. Or is the theme just supposed to be an ironic nod, saying that prom will crash and sink and all the attendees will abandon ship?

But that is too abstract. Might this prom theme be a political allusion to the GOP primaries? But then we must ask, where do the sympathies of the junior class lie--Romney, Paul, Santorum, or Gingrich? And who, pray tell, is the iceberg, who is the ship, and who are the people?

Perhaps the theme could even be a reference to a popular Kanye West remix, in which he says, "I call this club Titanic / why? 'Cause it's going down." That could be it.

So, in the interest of staying in good form, I propose the following prom themes for the next three years:

  • The 2013 prom will be "in honor" of Hurricane Katrina
  • The 2014 prom will be "in honor" of United Flight 93
  • The 2015 prom will be "in honor" of the Oklahoma City Bombing

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
No photo provided

Really?

First off we in no way will be mocking what happened, or even making fun of it. The Titanic has been regarded as one of the most majestic ships there have every been, there are still explorations going on nowadays to discover what it truly looked like.

Secondly, the Titanic movie (the one called The Titanic) was not an actual account of what happened. True, many characters in the movie were based off of real life characters but it was HIGHLY romanticized. Did you boycott the movie?

Thirdly, when looking at a historical situation it shouldn't be focused on solely the bad. When we hear Lincoln (as the example you stated) for most of us the first thought isn't "dead" same with every other character. What about a few years ago when they did a Hollywood themed prom? Did someone complain because lots of famous people are dead?

Lastly, by taking this approach can we no longer do a water theme, because too many boats have sank? Can we no longer do an air theme because of United Flight 93?

The point is, you can find bad in every situation that is exactly what everyone is doing. If you are really that infuriated by this theme, than simply don't go. We want everyone to go, but if you stick by what you say in this article just the mention of the Titanic will make you uncomfortable.

Evan Ramos's picture

Specifically Bad

The point is not that we (James and I at the minimum) think the theme is mocking the event or that we have found some tangential "bad" to go along with the Titanic. The point is that at the actual core of anything surrounding the Titanic is its sinking. Not the fluffy romantic stuff that happens in the first few minutes of James Cameron's Titanic movie.

Your counterexamples are particularly bad. We are not thinking of "Lincoln" and then looking for the bad, we are thinking of "Lincoln's assassination" *specifically* which shares an April 14 anniversary. Nor are we thinking of "all air travel" and looking for crashes to move to in our thought process. Likewise, this is not a Prom themed around sailing on a ship. It is Prom themed around the Titanic *specifically*, and it is inarguable that the Titanic equals sinking.

Kaila Simpson's picture

It's not about the sinking

It's not about the sinking although the sinking is what we usually associate with the titanic. It's about the romance of huge majestic boats that set sail to America in the early 1900's to a new world with new opportunities. Titanic was a huge beautiful boat and it hit an iceberg... Of course people died...but we are NOT celebrating that...we are celebrating aforementioned. Prom will be a magical night filled with enjoyment no matter the theme... I even thought the behind the bars theme (as mentioned in the April fools post) would've been hilariously fun!!!! and anyways its just a dance like get over it....

Also the three next proms you mentioned... that was completely out of line... Hurricane Katrina, United 93, and the Oklahoma bombing affected the entire country as a whole. There was bravery and devastation, there was actually something we could do to help those people because they were in such a struggle... The titanic... ok they died... like 100 years ago... there is nothing we can do... now the titanic is more a historical exploration. AND WHY NOT CELEBRATE NEW DISCOVERIES TO COME. All I am saying is if you don't like the theme....DONT GO... its that simple. BUT you will be missing out on a crap ton of fun... LIKE A BOSS.